Missives from the Verge with Allyson Shaw

Missives from the Verge with Allyson Shaw

Share this post

Missives from the Verge with Allyson Shaw
Missives from the Verge with Allyson Shaw
Against the Dying of the Light 🌒

Against the Dying of the Light 🌒

hope seeded in the darkest of places

Allyson Shaw's avatar
Allyson Shaw
Feb 05, 2025
∙ Paid
Share
A digital collage of giant standing stones in snow with low billowing clouds.  A big circle is indigo blue with a floral print and a geometric shape--many triangles overlaid. This is almost like a dark moon. IN the foreground a woman in 17th century attire--a woad blue dress and white apron with a head covering carries a basket and looks to the side with alert caution
This is a photo collage made with an image of the Stones of Stenness I took a year ago.

Hope and memory are deeply connected. —Rebecca Solnit.

The first part of Alison Balfour’s story, for paid subscribers, is here.

Become a paid subscriber to read it now.

On a cold day in December 1594, Alison Balfour was executed atop Gallows Ha, what is now known as Clay Loan. As the town gathered before the pyre, Alison spoke truth to power, declaring that her confession altogether ‘false and extortit.’ The notar wrote down her words, which I transcribe below.

Before I go on, I wonder what this means to us today, in this moment, to read Alison’s defiant words? What hope could a woman condemned to death grant us, over four hundred years after her execution?

I considered holding off on this post. It’s grim and distant, yet also troublingly familiar. I mulled it over, which is why this post is a bit late. Originally I wanted to post it at the new moon, but I worried—am I not reading the room? Here we are with our bruised hopes and coursing terrors in the present day. A war on women, trans and LGBTQ* folks is raging even as I type.

A woman died wrongly centuries ago. What of it? When she was supposed to proclaim her guilt as a witch to the crowd gathered to watch her die, she did something else entirely. To misquote Dylan Thomas, she raged against the dying of the light.

Perhaps it’s best to let her speak.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Allyson Shaw
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share